: Nyerere and Freire observation that not every kind of education is liberating one ; and if it has a liberation potential the mode or style of delivery in determining the potential by using the Tanzania education as relevance discuss this statement .
Introduction
Education is the process of passing society values, beliefs, norms, practices and tradition from one old generation to the younger generation. According to Nyerere (1967) depicted the Education for Self-Reliance (ESR) means delivering knowledge about ‘self-reliance’. According to Nyerere, the policy of self reliance means that Tanzanian’s development should depend on her natural resources. The concept of Education for Self Reliance is also about self-confidence, independence, responsibility and democratic involvement (Rahumbuka, 1974). Although ESR is supposed to liberate an individual and society, most of the African countries such as Tanzania seem to be lacking these elements as revealed by the problems facing the citizens including poverty, ignorance, moral decadence, false beliefs, social disintegration, economic dependence, exploitation and social injustice. The purpose of this paper is to provide an overview of the general aims of Education for Self Reliance and to highlight Nyerere’s recommendations for the policy of Education for Self Reliance with reference to Tanzania.
Education is the process of passing society values, beliefs, norms, practices and tradition from one old generation to the younger generation. According to Nyerere (1967) depicted the Education for Self-Reliance (ESR) means delivering knowledge about ‘self-reliance’. According to Nyerere, the policy of self reliance means that Tanzanian’s development should depend on her natural resources. The concept of Education for Self Reliance is also about self-confidence, independence, responsibility and democratic involvement (Rahumbuka, 1974). Although ESR is supposed to liberate an individual and society, most of the African countries such as Tanzania seem to be lacking these elements as revealed by the problems facing the citizens including poverty, ignorance, moral decadence, false beliefs, social disintegration, economic dependence, exploitation and social injustice. The purpose of this paper is to provide an overview of the general aims of Education for Self Reliance and to highlight Nyerere’s recommendations for the policy of Education for Self Reliance with reference to Tanzania.
Education
for Self Reliance (ESR), was the most important educational principle, which
presented the educational philosophy of Tanzania. The purpose of ESR was to set
down principles of education, which would serve as a revolutionary influence in
the creation of the new social society. ESR is about gaining self-independence,
responsibility and democratic involvement; it is education, which is meant to
liberate individual from over-reliance. However, the extent to which education
in most African countries like Tanzania has been able to meet its objectives in
terms of creating a sense of independence is still speculative. Also education
should be of relevance to the society; educated individual must serve the
society, education must be problem solving and education must be work oriented
According to Paulo Reglus Neves Freire September 19, 1921 – May 2, 1997) was a
Brazilian educator and philosopher who was a leading advocate of critical
pedagogy. He is best known for his influential work, Pedagogy of the Oppressed,
generally considered one of the foundational texts of the critical pedagogy
movement
Freire
was born on September 19, 1921 to a middle-class family in Recife, Pernambuco,
Brazil. He became familiar with poverty and hunger from an early age, during
the Great Depression. In 1931, his family moved to the less expensive city of
Jaboatão dos Guararapes. On October 31, 1934, his father died
Freirean
literacy methods have been adopted throughout the developing world In the
Philippines, Catholic "basal Christian communities" adopted Freire's
methods in community educationPapua New Guinea, Freirean literacy methods were
used as part of the World Bank funded Southern Highlands Rural Development
Program's Literacy Campaign. Freirean approaches also lie at the heart of the
"Dragon Dreaming" approach to community programs that have spread to
20 countries by 2014
Education Should be Relevant to the
Society
Nyerere reiterated that education
at all levels should be relevant to the community in which a learner lives.
A learner should be in a position to live in a village and contribute, through
work, to the development of that particular village. The foreign conception of
education, that the Educated must serve the Society, which is usually isolated
for the society, should be shunned and instead be replaced by value-oriented
and integrated education (Nyerere, 1968).
Education has to foster the social
goals of living together for the common goal. It has to
prepare our young people to play a dynamic and constructive part in the
development of a society where all people share equitably for the good of the
group, and which its progress is quantified in relation to human well-being,
not cars, prestige buildings, or other such things, whether privately or
publicly owned. Therefore, our education must teach a sense of commitment to
the general society and help the society to accept the standards suitable to a
better future not those appropriate to the colonial past (Nyerere, 1968).
Nyerere’s emphasis on the importance and relevance of education to
society bears much similarity with the Russian policy of education, which
stipulates that to educate a member of the soviet society means to educate that
person so that he/she can understand the interests of the Russian society and
that such a person shall have no personal interests which are opposed to the
collective interests (Curtis, 1968). In the same way, the educational system of
Tanzania should be relevant to the society in order to form an individual who
can easily cope with the real situation in Tanzania and be able to utilize
his/her education, in his or her own circumstances and give contribution to
his/her own society. Nyerere’s conviction on the power of a teacher to create
the quality education reveal as he says, “the teacher’s power is the power to
decide whether “service” or “self” shall be dominant motive in Tanzania of 1990
and thereafter” (Nyerere, 1967).
Nyerere, in education for
self-reliance emphasizes that all able bodied people including the intellectuals
must work. He states:
For
the truth is that many of the people in Tanzania regards education as meaning
that an educated man is too precious for the uneven and devastating life which
the society still live… even during the holidays we believe that young people
and women should be protected from uneven work; neither they nor the society
expect them to spend their time on stiff physical labour or on jobs which are
not comfortable and are not pleasant….it is a reflection of the attitude we
have all adopted (Nyerere, 1967).
Nyerere urges and calls for a
method of learning by doing. The practical method
recommended is not only to aim at manual labor, but such learning by doing must
be directed towards a productive, constructive or creative end which should
lead in the long run to solving the problems of the society. Nyerere shows
dissatisfaction with the students’ participation or contribution in solving
problems of society, when he says: How many of our students devote their
holidays doing a job which could recover people’s lives without money; jobs
similar to digging a drainage channel for a village, or representing the
construction and explaining the importance of deep-pit latrines? Few have done
such work in the National Youth Camps or through nation building schemes,
organized by schools but they are the exception rather than the rule (Nyerere,
1968).
Nyerere is appealing to the educated to liberate the masses from human
suffering. The concept of education emerges at the same time in Freire’s
book, On Liberating Education through his method of critical dialogical
encounter. The publication of Freire’s book coincides with the proclamation of
Nyerere’s education for self-reliance. Freire’s second major educational book, Pedagogy
of the oppressed was published in 1972. This work too advocates problem-solving
education, which is called ‘liberating education’. It is thus difficult to say
whether or not Nyerere’s policy of education for self-reliance was influenced
by Freire’s works. As regards relevance of education, Nyerere is establishing a
delicate balance between the desire to access universal knowledge and the
imperative to make that knowledge of use in our situation.
During his childhood and
adolescence at school, Freire ended up four grades behind, and his social life
revolved around playing pick-up football with other poor children, from whom he
states to have learned a great deal. These experiences
would shape his concerns for the poor and would help to construct his particular
educational viewpoint. Freire stated that poverty and hunger severely affected
his ability to learn. These experiences influenced his decision to dedicate his
life to improving the lives of the poor: "I didn't understand anything
because of my hunger. I wasn't dumb. It wasn't lack of interest. My social
condition didn't allow me to have an education. Experience showed me once again
the relationship between social class and knowledge" .Eventually, his
family's misfortunes turned around and their prospects improved.
Freire
enrolled in law school at the University of Recife in 1943. He also studied
philosophy, more specifically phenomenology, and the psychology of language.
Although admitted to the legal bar, he never practiced law and instead worked as
a secondary school Portuguese teacher.
Freire was appointed municipal
Secretary of Education.
Paulo
Freire contributed a philosophy of education which blended classical approaches
stemming from Plato and modern Marxist, post-Marxist and anti-colonialist
thinkers. His Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968) can be read as an extension of,
or reply to, Frantz Fanon's The Wretched of the Earth (1961), which emphasized
the need to provide native populations with an education which was
simultaneously new and modern, rather than traditional, and anti-colonial not simply an extension of the colonizing
culture.
In
Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Freire,
reprising the oppressors–oppressed distinction, applies the distinction to
education, championing that education should allow the oppressed to regain
their sense of humanity, in turn overcoming their condition. Nevertheless, he
acknowledges that for this to occur, the oppressed individual must play a role
in their liberation.
No
pedagogy which is truly liberating can remain distant from the oppressed by
treating them as unfortunates and by presenting for their emulation models from
among the oppressors. The oppressed must be their own example in the struggle
for their redemption.
Likewise,
oppressors must be willing to rethink their way of life and to examine their
own role in oppression if true liberation is to occur: "those who
authentically commit themselves to the people must re-examine themselves
constantly".
Freire believed education could not
be divorced from politics; the act of teaching and learning
are considered political acts in and of themselves. Freire defined this
connection as a main tenet of critical pedagogy. Teachers and students must be
made aware of the politics that surround education. The way students are taught
and what they are taught serves a political agenda. Teachers, themselves, have
political notions they bring into the classroom.
Freire
believed that "education makes sense because women and men learn that
through learning they can make and remake themselves, because women and men are
able to take responsibility for themselves as beings capable of knowing—of
knowing that they know and knowing that they don't.
Banking model of education
In
terms of pedagogy, Freire is best known for his attack on what he called the
"banking" concept of education, in which students are viewed as empty
accounts to be filled by teachers. He notes that "it transforms students
into receiving objects attempts to control thinking and action, leading men and
women to adjust to the world, inhibiting their creative power.The basic
critique was not entirely novel, and paralleled Rousseau's conception of
children as active learners, as opposed to a tabula rasa view, more akin to the
banking mode. John Dewey was also strongly critical of the transmission of mere
facts as the goal of education. Dewey often described education as a mechanism
for social change, stating that "education is a regulation of the process
of coming to share in the social consciousness; and that the adjustment of
individual activity on the basis of this social consciousness is the only sure
method of social reconstruction frère’s work revived this view and placed it in
context with contemporary theories and practices of education, laying the
foundation for what would later be termed critical pedagogy.
Culture of silence .According
to Freire, in equal social relations create a 'culture of silence' that instill
a negative, passive and suppressed self-image onto the oppressed, and learners
must, then, develop a critical consciousness in order to recognize that this
culture of silence is created to oppress .A culture of silence can also cause
the "dominated individuals lose the means by which to critically respond
to the culture that is forced on them by a dominant culture
He considers social, race and class
dynamics to be interlaced into the conventional education system, through which
this culture of silence eliminates the "paths of thought that lead to a
language of critique
Legacy and impact. Since
the publication of the English edition in 1970, Pedagogy of the Oppressed has
had a large impact in education and pedagogy worldwide especially as a defining
work of critical pedagogy. According to Israeli writer and education reform
theorist Sol Stern, it has "achieved near-iconic status in America's
teacher-training programs".[citation needed] Connections have also been
made between Freire's non-dualism theory in pedagogy and Eastern philosophical
traditions such as the Advaita Vedanta.
He
suggest that if the children are working
as well as learning they will therefore be able to learn less academically, and
that this will affect standards of administration, in the professions and
so on, throughout our nation in time to come. In fact it is doubtful whether
this is necessarily so; the recent tendency to admit children to primary
schools at ages of 5 and 6 years has almost certainly meant that less can be
taught at the early stages. The reversion to 7 or 8 years entrance will allow
the pace to be increased somewhat; the older children inevitably learn a little
faster. A child is unlikely to learn less academically if his studies are
related to the life he sees around him.
But even if this suggestion were
based on provable fact, it could not he allowed to over-ride the need for
change in the direction of educational integration with our national life.
For the majority of our people the thing which matters is that they should be
able to read and write fluently in Swahili, that they should have an ability to
do arithmetic, and that they should know something of the history, values, and
workings of their country and their Government, and that they should acquire
the skills necessary to earn their living. (It is important to stress that in
Tanzania most people will earn their living by working on their own or on a
communal shamba, and only a few will do so by working for wages which they have
to spend on buying things the farmer produces for himself.) Things like health
science, geography, and the beginning of English, are also important,
especially so that the people who wish may be able to learn more by themselves
in later life. But most important of all is that our primary school graduates
should be able to fit into, and to serve, the communities from which they come.
The same principles of integration
into the community, and applicability to its needs, must also be followed at
post-secondary levels, but young people who have been through
such an integrated system of education as that outlined are unlikely to forget
their debt to the community by an intense period of study at the end of their
formal educational life. Yet even at university, medical school, or other
post-secondary levels, there is no reason why students should continue to have
all their washing up and cleaning done for them. Nor is there any reason why
students at such institutions should not be required as part of their degree or
professional training, to spend at least part of their vacations contributing
to the society in a manner related to their studies. At present some
undergraduates spend their vacations working in Government offices—getting paid
at normal employee rates for doing so. It would be more appropriate (once the
organization had been set up efficiently) for them to undertake projects needed
by the community, even if there is insufficient money for them to constitute
paid employment.
Conclusion
The
education provided by Tanzania for the students of Tanzania must serve the
purposes of Tanzania. It must encourage the growth of the socialist values we
aspire to. It must encourage the development of a proud, independent and free
citizenry which relies upon itself for its own development, and which knows the
advantages and the problems of co-operation. It must ensure that the educated
know themselves to be an integral part of the nation and recognize the
responsibility to give greater service the greater the opportunities they have
had. ,
Comments
Post a Comment