Assessment on the Influence of Small Scale Fishing In Household Economic Growth. A Case Study Of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal

 

STELLA MARIS MTWARA UNIVERSITY COLLEGE

(STEMMUCO)

(A Constituent College of St. Augustine University of Tanzania)

 

                                       FACULTY OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION

 

Assessment on the Influence of Small Scale Fishing In Household Economic Growth.

A Case Study Of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal

 

A Research Proposal Submitted for the Partial Fulfillment for the Requirements of Degree of Bachelor of business administration  at Stella Maris Mtwara University College

 

Kalimang’asi Charles  S.

STE/BBA/123137

 

2019


CHAPTER ONE

GENERAL INTRODUCTION

1.0  Introduction

This chapter included the background of the study, statement of the problem, research objectives, research question and the significance of the study.

1.1 Background of the Study

From earliest time, fishing has been a major source of food for human and a provider of employment and economic benefits to those who are engaging in this activity. Although, with the increased knowledge and the dynamic development of fisheries, it has been realized that aquatic living resources, though are renewable, are not infinite and need to be properly managed, their contribution to the nutritional, economic and social wellbeing of the growing world's population is sustained (FAO, 2005)

Many millions of people around the world find a source of income and livelihood in the fisheries and aquaculture sector. For the last five decades global fish production has grown in an increasing of food fish supply at an average of 3.2 percent annually, outpacing world population growth by 1.6 percent (FAO, 2014).World Bank, FAO and World Fish Center, reported there is an estimated annual production of 48 million tons of fish originating from small-scale fisheries (De Graaf et al., 2011). Basically the world per capita apparent fish consumption has increased from an average of 9.9 kg in the 1960s to 19.2 kg in 2012. This impressive development has been driven by a combination of population growth, rising incomes and urbanization, and is facilitated by the strong expansion of fish production and more efficient distribution of channels (FAO, 2014).

China has been responsible for most of the growth in fish availability, owing to the dramatic expansion in its fish production, particularly from aquaculture. Its per capita apparent fish consumption also has increased at an average annual rate of 6.0 percent in 2 the period 1990 -2010 to about 35.1 kg in 2010. Annual per capita fish supply in the rest of the world was about 15.4 kg in 2010 (11.4 kg in the 1960s and 13.5 kg in the 1990s (FAO, 2014).In Tanzania the average per capita annual fish and shellfish consumption is estimated to be 5.5 kg(USAID, 2015). By the year 2012about 58.3 million people engaged in the primary sector of capture fisheries and aquaculture, where 37 percent engaged in full time, 84 percent of all people employed in the fisheries and aquaculture sector are in Asia, followed by Africa which has more than 10 percent (FAO, 2014).

Employment in fisheries sector has grown faster than the world’s population. Overall, women accounted for more than 15 percent of all people directly engaged in the fisheries primary sector in 2012. The proportion of women exceeded 20 percent in inland water fishing and up to 90 percent in secondary activities especially processing. FAO estimates that, overall, fisheries and aquaculture assure the livelihoods of 10 to12 percent of the world’s population (FAO, 2014).

World Bank (2012) found that in Africa, the total employment in the whole fisheries sector at 25.4 million people, 7.8 million were employed in fishing and 17.6 in postharvest. MLDF (2010) reported that, in Tanzania more than 4 million people engaged in fishing and fisheries related activities, while more than 400 000 fisheries operators are directly employed in the sector.

Tanzania is among of the Country in Africa which is endowed with water resources, sharing three of the largest inland lakes in Africa, namely Lake Victoria, Lake Tanganyika and Lake Nyasa, diverse river systems, numerous wetlands, and the Indian Ocean. The 3 country is reasonably rich in marine and inland fishery resources making the fisheries sector important in the economy (Sobo, 2012). Both fish culture and capture fisheries has contributed much in Tanzanian economy. The contribution of the aquaculture to national food security and economic development is extrapolated at 1522.80 tones. This is about 0.435 percent of the average annual fish landings which is around 350 000 tones. At present aquaculture is largely a subsistence activity practiced by poor households in the coastal and inland areas but the benefits arising from it are several, it contributes to people's requirements for animal protein, particularly in the rural areas where there are no capture fisheries, and it provides employment opportunities and is a source of income (FAO, 2010).

It is also reported by FAO (2012) that, Tanzania is among of the main producer of fish for inland fisheries in Africa where mostly fishing in the Lake Victoria and Lake Tanganyika. The major commercial species in Lake Victoria are Nile perch (Lates niloticus); Rastrineobola argentea commonly known as “Dagaa” and Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus); while the major commercial species in Lake Tanganyika are the Centropomidae (Lates stappersii) (commonly known as “Migebuka”). Tanzania was ranking in the top 10worldwide as a producer of inland waters capture (FAO, 2014) and was amongst top 10 countries in Africa in terms of total capture fisheries production (FAO, 2003).

For marine fisheries, the commercial marine fisheries are mainly concentrated in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) targeting the tuna and tuna-like species. The major tuna and tuna-like species contributing to the catches include Yellow fin tuna, Skipjack tuna, Big eye tuna, Long tail tuna, and Kawakawa (Anon, 2005). Small scale fishing however is conducted by artisanal fishers who fish for fin fish, mollusks and crustaceans within the 4 inshore. Tanzania as the Eastern Africa Region, among 13 African countries and 57 countries in the world produced over 200 000 metric tons in 2010 (FAO, 2012). The total annual fish production in Tanzania was 347,157 metric tons in 2010 (MLFD, 2010) and reported as the main source of protein to nearly 9 million people living along the coast, and provides source of employment and livelihood to a substantial number of people (MLFD, 2010).

 The contribution of fishing activities has remained fairly constant over the last decade ranging between 4.4% and 5.7% per annum and a period average of 4.6%. Starting from a low 2.9% annual growth in 2000, the sector’s growth rate increased to around 6% between 2002 and 2005, and has since steadily dropped to 1.5% in 2010. The decrease in growth between 2009 and 2010 has been attributed to illegal fishing, and destruction of nursery grounds. Currently, the sector accounts for about 10% of the national exports (Planning Commission, 2012; MLFD, 2014).

Small-scale or artisanal fisheries is still developing rapidly through export markets and adopting new technologies like satellite positioning systems which make easier for fishers to search fish (Hamidu, 2012).In fact, a large number of the people in Tanzania who are living in coastal zone are surrounded by rich marine resources. They utilize the resources for subsistence and as a source of income in the households. Among of the resources, fish being the most important compared to others, (Jidawwi and Ohman, 2002). Different fishing gears are being used to capture those marine resources though they are none sophisticated. At least each household is engaging in fishing activity either direct or indirect often benefits from such resources. Although fishing has been conducted for 5 several years, still continues to be an important source of household income and food as well.

1.2 Statement of the Problem

Tanzania is gifted with water resources, and is sharing with other three countries of the largest inland lakes in Africa, which are Lake Victoria, Lake Tanganyika and Lake Nyasa with diverse river systems, abundant wetlands, and the Indian Ocean. The country is rationally rich in marine and inland fishery resources making the fisheries sector important in the economy; thus it cannot be understated (Sobo 2012). Fisheries provide substantial employment, income, livelihoods, recreation; foreign earnings and revenue to the country (Sobo, 2012).

Marine and inland fisheries are very significant in household in terms of food security and nutrition. Fish provides a significant contribution to animal protein consumption (FAO, 2008). Fisheries also provide both direct and indirect employment. Through employment the income earned from both fisheries and associated activities such as fish processing, fishing agreements, license fees, and from the activities of distant water fishing fleets which are serviced at regional ports contribute to government budgets and to the gross domestic product (FAO, 2008).

According to FAO (2005) majority of households in developing countries are involved in fishing activities either fishers or in fishing related activities whether fulltime, temporary or occasional however there are no clear distinctions between those who are fishing for subsistence and those for income. Moreover, even where fishing is the main livelihood activity within the household, it hardly ever accounts for the entire cash income. Allison and Ellis (2001) also reported that in most developing countries fisheries have often been 6 described as a last resort occupation in household. In the fishing communities, fisheries have a direct link to household incomes. These household incomes explain the levels of income in these fishing communities which in the end indicate whether a given fishing household is poor or otherwise. In Lake Victoria, the household engaged in fishing (fishers) received net income that ranged between $1300 and $2100,while for gear owner earned $5200 and $8400 per month (Bilame, 2012).It is also reported that about 40–55% of the income of coastal fishing households in Tanzania is generated by fishing, (Ninnes, 2004)

Similarly Mafia Island is among of the District in Tanzania where the dwellers are practicing fishing and the activity is being supported by the fish processing industry which is located at Kilindoni village where some of the fish products are being sold. Despite the fact that fishing seems to be the main economic activity as explained in the district profile, there is no reliable information that explains the contribution of fishing to the household income .It is therefore appropriate to determine its contribution to the household income.

1.3 Objective of the Study

1.3.1 General Objectives

The objective of the study was to assess the influence of small scale fishing in household economic growth. A case study of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal

1.3.2 Specific Objectives

        i.            To identify the contribution of small scale fishing in household economic growth

      ii.            To assess the challenges facing small scale fishing in household economic growth

    iii.            To analyze the solutions to the challenges facing small scale fishing in household economic growth

1.4  Research Questions

i)        What are the contributions of small scale fishing in household economic growth?

ii)      What are the challenges facing small scale fishing in household economic growth?

i)        What are the solutions to the challenges facing small scale fishing in household economic growth?

1.5 Significance of the Study

The study will provide more information on the importance of fishing and its related activities within the household for the people living in Mtwara Mikindani. It will raise awareness on the importance of small -scale fisheries not only because their livelihoods depend on sustainable natural resources base but, because fisheries provide vital local nutritious food and a safety net for many poor household around the community.

Fisheries are of immense scale and economic importance, which also means they have a significant environmental impact that must be managed effectively to ensure sustainability.

The coastal fishing communities in Tanzania are particularly sensitive to  climate change due to their high dependence on fisheries for food security and livelihoods. Conservation and adaptive management strategies that foster sustainable fish populations and equitable distribution of resources are urgently needed to mitigate the negative consequences caused by challenges. Furthermore, the findings of the study are useful for future reference to other researchers who are interested to work further in fisheries studies.

1.6       Scope of the Study

The study will be conducted in Mtwara Mikindani Municipality. The study will involve four selected wards of Mikindani, Chuno, Shangani and Msangamkuu that are located along the Indian Ocean in the Municipal and all matured people who live in this region permanently or temporarily. This area will enable the researchers to make in depth assessment about the problem. Research will not be studied on the other Municipals found in the region because are not areas of concerns.

1.7 Limitations of the Study

The study will encounter several limitations particularly during the data collection exercise. Some households’ will not willing to disclose their income level information due to the fear that their information would be exposed to the community in spite of the researcher’s effort to explain the purpose of the study. The problem will be minimized by changing the questions and the way of justifying questions. This will make them (households) to disclose their information unknowingly.

Some of the respondents will be unable to recall their exact daily income. This will be thought because of the nature of markets for their product especially the fish markets which will be Fishing related activities  Fish processing,  Fish trade,  Vessel making,  Casual work,  Ice production and Fish market, Fishing season, Financial support, Fishing gear, Education level Dependent variable Intermediate variable Independent variable Fishing activity Household income  based on bargaining modalities. There will be no formal or standard measurement which will be used to measure fish which will be sold in landing site; some use trey, buckets, etc. Therefore not only that they will fail to remember monthly income generated from fishing, but also the amount they sold will be difficult to recall. This will be minimized by asking the respondents the number of fishing days and the average income they obtained daily.

General election Some of the respondents will be not ready to answer some of the questions presuming that the researcher will be collecting information that could be used for campaign, but the researcher will assure them that the study is only for research purposes.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER TWO

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1       Introduction

Research as systematic process of searching information should be trace on what others did previously to the related problem; hence this chapter deals with reviewing on the various literatures about the contribution of Indian Ocean towards socio-economic developments of various parts of the world.

3 Investigating the Importance of SSF (i)

Employment Opportunities Estimates of global employment within the SSF sector are varied and considered biased by the definition of a ‘fisher’3 . Yet, in the developing world more than one hundred million people are thought to currently depend directly upon SSF and postharvest activities (fish processing and fish trading) for at least part of their income (Béné 2006; Béné et al. 2010a). SSF also employs millions of fishery associated workers including fish processors, carpenters, transporters and traders of goods critical to the sector (ice, salt, petrol food; and non-food goods) as well as fish. In contrast, employment opportunities in the domain of large (industrial) operations are considered relatively limited due to the advanced technology in use (FAO 2007; FAO 2008). For example the marine SSF sector is said to employ up to twenty-five times more workers than its industrial-scale counterpart (Pauly 2006, cited in Jacquet 2009).

In West Africa more than 60% of the population are aged thirty or less and are largely under-employed, with few paid working or educational opportunities (Cockayne and Williams 2009). For some, SSF is seen to provide a critical opportunity. Coastal areas on all continents offer resources, variable extractive opportunities and living spaces that prove attractive (Brugère et al. 2008). West African population densities along the narrow Atlantic coastal fringe have soared (both intrinsically and through in-migration) illustrating a willingness to relocate coast-wards in search of opportunity (Vogt et al. 2010) Globally the rate at which individuals are entering fishing (and fish farming) is said to be higher than population growth (World Bank 2008). However, this is contested by other reports declaring that regional variation does exist. For example, growth of fisheries is reportedly in decline in Malaysia, stable in Tanzania and slowing considerably in Bangladesh (Tietze et al. 2000)

Exponential growth of SSF in West Africa challenges one common belief that all fishers typically descend from a long-standing history in the activity. More than 90% of SSF in the region are considered new-arrivals or displaced entrants, indicating that fishing does present an opportunity (Chauveau et al. 2007). Mobility into fishing has been linked with widespread regional unemployment; drought, poor soil and unfavourable farming conditions; conflict, land reforms and the rising price of fish relative to agricultural produce. However, in general it is argued that we know very For some, growth of SSF is the most worrying development, said to be creating an accumulation of effort ultimately detrimental to fishery resources (Pauly 1997). Others argue that fisheries, like numerous other small-scale production activities4 , are most often described as an occupation of last resort or a last-chance effort for desperate, unskilled, jobless and destitute people; when really the porosity and accessibility of SSF is a huge advantage, given its prevalence in developing countries where alternative employment opportunities are rare (Allison and Ellis 2001; JulLarsen 2002, Jul-Larsen and van Zweiten 2004; Béné 2006; McClanahan et al. 2009; Béné 2010a). This capacity of the SSF sector to absorb surplus labour (providing a “safety net” or “labour buffer”) creating alternative sources of food, employment and income; and socially protecting the unskilled, unemployed and the unfortunate, is seen from a poverty reduction perspective as the sector's greatest merit (Jul-Larsen et al. 2002; Béné 2006; Béné et al. 2010a; Béné 2011; Njock and Westlund 2010). This is considered particularly relevant for those whose “normal” means of income- generation has been disrupted; in periods of individual or collective turmoil, in the face of short-term unexpected shocks, forced migrations, displacements and crises; due to civil wars, natural disasters, political and social upheaval (FAO 2008). Furthermore, it is argued that the skills exhibited by individuals arriving into fishing, are largely undocumented; but where they have been captured they have been proven to be numerous, varied and multi-sectoral (Hannesson 2002). The processes which have shaped decisions to enter SSF, have been documented for East African and Asian fisheries in particular (Pollnac et al. 2001; Cinner et al. 2009; Islam and Herbeck 2013). The West African marine SSF literature lacks an attention to this detail (Allison and Horemans 2004). This study therefore aims to disaggregate the largely undifferentiated West African fishers in this regard, to investigate the variability in entry strategies and how these shape the dynamics of the resultant commercial SSF sector.

Access and Conflict In West Africa, the 1982 curtailment of ‘freedom of the seas’5 transferred control of coastal property into the hands of each national state. Coastal property encompasses territorial waters (demarcated twelve nautical miles offshore) and EEZ’s restricting exploration activities within 200 nautical miles (Witbooi 2008; Alder and Sumaila 2004). One year later, fishing authorisation was further centralised within each EEZ, as localised authority over fishing grounds was smothered by a ‘higher’ State-level responsibility (Binet 2012). Today, SSF prevails in 136 maritime countries, many of 5 UNCLOS the UN Convention on the Law Of the Sea The Importance of Small-Scale Fishing to Rural Coastal Livelihoods 10 which are characterised by confused and poorly defined property rights, which often result in de facto open access that operates under a regime of nominal State governance (Andrew et al. 2007; Cheong 2008; Teh and Sumaila 2013). A prevalence of conflict associated with expansion of the fisheries sector, movements (migrations) of fishers in West Africa and underlying confusion over access-rights have all been highlighted (Wilson et al. 1994; Atti-Mama et al. 1999).

Apparent open-access conditions often result from an overshadowing of localised, legitimate and often more effective pre-existing tenure regimes. These pre-existing systems have been documented for various natural resources, including fisheries, water-stores and forests. One widely-documented comprises the common property resource (CPR) system in which resources are controlled by a group who agree to abide by rules regulating membership and use (Ostrom 1990; Johnson 2004). Despite their relative strengths, CPR systems are by nature hugely vulnerable to both competition and encroachment, particularly from larger and more powerful political and economic systems (Smith and Wishnie 2000). Erosion of CPR systems has occurred to such an extent that they are now considered as endangered as the resources which they evolved to defend. Examples of CPR systems, where they do persist have become a focus for investigating collective management. There have also been widespread efforts to use their organisational structure as a model, through which to establish management systems de novo as ‘community based’ initiatives. CPR systems are defined as critical institutions which can mediate the relationship between a population and the environment. They are considered particularly useful when a population changes in size or composition (Curran and Agardy 2002). The Importance of Small-Scale Fishing to Rural Coastal Livelihoods 11 However, despite a growing body of practical support for the recently emerging community-based management ideals (many of which attempt to re-create CPR systems) numerous shortfalls have been identified

Through these constraints, the co-management agenda emerges as a silver-bullet, widely discussed yet believed by very few to harbour any potential for conservation goals, good governance of natural resources or improved rural livelihoods (Nielson and Lund 2012). Instead, the ‘community’ it is argued, which forms the foundation of natural resource management re-form, is at best dynamic and at worst, a ‘myth’, emerging from the multiple social relations that people create (Cleaver 2002; Blaikie 2006). The issue of elite capture is raised, which Jentoft (2005) cautions, develops when collaborative management empowers the elite; entrenching inequalities which already exist. Béné et al (2011) concur, explaining that in the majority of cases involving fisheries, attempts to improve governance have simply modified the statusquo by altering power distributions among stakeholders. Instead, an ‘elite’ or privileged group have been frequently observed to hijack management reforms, in order to serve their own interests (Njaya et al. 2012). Due to the tendency for SSF to work closer to shore where smaller stocks are often targeted, collisions of interest with weakly supported customary governance systems overlooked by central State authority are a particular problem (Berkes 2003). Where these localised systems are over-ridden by larger management agendas, confusion often emerges as different groups variably interpret access, use and harvesting rights. Out of this confusion, the ‘dilemma’ of open-access emerges, a first-come first

2.4       Research Gap

There are various researches that have been conducted in Mtwara municipal concerning with the Indian Ocean on the municipal. Most of these researches have based on the negative influence of human on the resources available on the Indian Ocean such as pollution, degradation and loss of biodiversities.

Akwilapo 2011), Emeritus et al (2012) in their studies conducted on coastal region of Mtwara, the findings of those studies revealed the bad practices done by the indigenous of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal in destructing the resources in the Indian Ocean. There were no any other studies to assess on how Indian Ocean was contributing to socio-economic development of Mtwara Mikindani. Their studies involved two districts of Mtwara urban and Mtwara rural specifically from the wards and villages located along the Indian Ocean. Therefore, were differ from the sample size and design because of being wider in scope. Moreover, their findings revealed the contribution of Oceanic resources but they failed to assess on how those resources contribute to socio0economic development of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal.

 Therefore, this study was aiming to assess the contribution of Indian Ocean in Mtwara Mikindani Municipal so as to assess the expected development of Mtwara Mikindani from Indian Ocean, on why is not similar to the other areas that are located along the Indian Ocean such as Dar es Salaam and Tanga, where its development were highly contributed by the Indian Ocean. The findings of this study intended to show the contributions of Indian Ocean towards socio-economic development of Mtwara Mikindani Municipal and looking the challenges that might cause low contribution of Ocean in the Municipal.

 

 

CHAPTER THREE

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.0       Introduction

This chapter focused on the research methodology, which will be used in the study. The research will use; research design, area of the study, targeted population, population sampling and method of collecting data.

3.1       Research Design

The researcher used a conceptual structure with which the study were conducted, the study engaged on both descriptive and quantitative designs so as to admit full qualitative and quantitative  presentation of data of the facts collected to the selected study areas.

3.2       Area of the Study

The study was conducted in Mtwara urban District where by a researcher will select ten wards. Mtwara region laid between longitudes 380 and 40030" East of Greenwich. It is also situated between latitudes 100 05" and 110 25" South of the equator. It borders Lindi region to the north, the Indian Ocean to the east and separated by the Ruvuma River from Mozambique in the south. To the west it borders Ruvuma region. According to general report of 2012 census Mtwara – District is population of comprised of 3.9 households who depend much in trade and fishing, the main tribe in the region is Makonde while Makua, Yao and Mwera form the minority but not underestimated.

Source; STEMMUCO Geography lab (2017)

3.3       Targeted Population

Population refers to the totality of any group units which have one or more traits in common that are of interest to the research. According to census report of (2012), Mtwara Mikindani contained about 336,302 of population.

The study was conducted in Mtwara Mikindani Municipal with viewed to the selected wards of Mikindani, Chuno, Shangani andMsangamkuuthe local communities in these areas may have clear information on contribution of Indian Ocean towards socio-economic development because they are located near to the Indian Ocean and whereby the offices are found to get various in formations to accomplish this study.

3.4       Sample and Sampling Techniques

Beck and Polit (2004) defines sample as the subset of population selected to participate in the study. The sample size was obtained basing on the rule of thumb proposed by John (1984), the rule directed that; for (0-100) population should be used for data collection. Guided to this rule, the study the study used 650 as a targeted population from the general population of 336,302 as according to the rule of thumb by John (1984). Under which from 65 respondents included; fishing officer, tourism officer, and port, port officers,fisheries, traders and local community from wards of Shangani, Chuno, Mikindani and Msangamkuu.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 3.1 Showing Sampling Sizes

Category of respondents

Frequency

Total

Male

Female

Port officers

1

1

2

Fishing officers

3

-

3

Tourism officer

1

-

1

Community development officer

-

1

1

Fisheries

15

-

15

Traders /local traders

10

10

20

Local community

14

9

23

Total

35

30

65

 

Source: Field Data (2017)                                                                  

3.5       Data Collection Techniques

The researcher applied the following methods in data collection; Observation, Interview, Questionnaires and Documentation

3.5.1    Observation

According to Kothari (2004), observation is the common method of data collection in field research. The researcher will use method especially area observation in order to get the first hand comprehensive information so as to understand the studied problem. During the study, the researcher used personal observation to observe various socio-economic activities that rely on Indian Ocean that can contribute something towards socio-economic development of Mtwara Mikindani municipal.

3.5.2    Interview

Kothari (2004) defines interview as, a method used to collect data by asking oral and written questions. The researcher used interview so as to give room to the respondents, since this was the most effective way of conversation that gives everyone to express his/her knowledge over the problems. Also, the researcher used interview because it gives the chance to get more information about the problem through asking questions.

3.5.3    Questionnaires

The researcher used questionnaires as a tool of gathering relevant data and information from the people who concern with the use of Indian Ocean and its resources direct or indirect. Both close question and open ended questions were used by the researcher. The researcher intended to use indigenous people, fishing officers, tourism officers, port officers and other people of concern.

3.5.4    Documentary Analysis

 This involves get information by critical analysis and written material of an origination such text books, newspaper articles, speech and magazines, where these helped a researcher to meet with the research goals.

3.6       Data Analysis

Data analysis is the process of bringing order, structure and meaning to collected information (Mugenda et al. (1999). In analysis of data qualitative methods will be applied, which implied editing, coding, classification, graphics, presentation as well as collection of tabulated data, Qualitative data were described using words. In analyzing data, a researcher used Microsoft excels to obtain charts and graphs for easily interpretation.

 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

International Law

KATIBA YA KIKUNDI